So, I had a battle report started a couple of weeks ago on a battle, but then halfway through the computer I was using died, without any chance to get the file off. So, since I thought the computer would never live again, I finished the battle without typing it up. And then my Dad managed to temporarily resurrect the computer, and I got my file back. So, I'll give a detailed description for the first 7 or 8 turns, and then a general summary for the last part of the battle. Here goes:
I thought I would give my new goblins a spin, so I devised a little game between some elves and goblins/orcs. Basically, I set a 500 point limit for both sides. I don't really have enough trees to make a proper forest (there's a good gift idea by the way) but I threw a couple out on the board to give it a woody feel.
Here are the starting forces:
Good side:
8 high elves with bow
7 high elves with sword
8 wood elves with spear
9 wood elves with sword
Glorfindel
High elf captain
Evil side:
8 goblins with sword and shield
8 goblins with spear
8 goblins with bow
4 orcs with bow
1 orc with banner and shield
1 orc with two-handed weapon
10 orcs with sword and shield
10 orcs with spear
Cave Troll
Durburz, Goblin king
Orc captain
The good side, of course, gained priority to start things out. They moved up slightly to take advantage of cover, but mostly remained in their defensive position. The orcs, on the other hand, along with the goblins, moved forward quickly. Because the goblins can only move four inches at a time, as opposed to the 6 inches that just about everyone else can move, they fell behind the orcs a bit (Note: There are no pictures for the first 3 rounds because I forgot to get my Mom's camera before I started...).
The second turn was basically the same as the first. No one was in range of the other side's archers yet, so no arrows were fired.
The third turn, the orc archers finally got in range of the elves' bows and the elves unleashed a barrage of arrows, but failed to wound anyone.
The evil side gained priority once again. The orc archers were finally in range to return fire, but they failed to hit anyone. The elves, on the other hand, finally found a target and picked off one of the orc archers.
The good side gained priority in the fifth turn as the elven archers unleashed another shower of arrows on the orcs. One orc archer was killed as a result. The goblin archers, who were finally in range, let loose in return and killed one elven archer.
In the sixth turn, the evil side gained priority; the front line of orcs waited for the goblins to catch up to them, in preparation for a charge on the elves. The elves, on the other hand, made their own preparations for combat. The goblin archers managed to pick off one elven archer, while the elves only killed one goblin.
The evil side moved forward slightly, but they couldn't get into combat. The elves, however, charged madly into combat. Three orcs were killed in the fighting, while four elves were taken down (really really bad dice rolls by the elves...tons of 1's). The goblin archers took down another elf, while the elven archers missed again.
Here are the starting forces:
Good side:
8 high elves with bow
7 high elves with sword
8 wood elves with spear
9 wood elves with sword
Glorfindel
High elf captain
Evil side:
8 goblins with sword and shield
8 goblins with spear
8 goblins with bow
4 orcs with bow
1 orc with banner and shield
1 orc with two-handed weapon
10 orcs with sword and shield
10 orcs with spear
Cave Troll
Durburz, Goblin king
Orc captain
The good side, of course, gained priority to start things out. They moved up slightly to take advantage of cover, but mostly remained in their defensive position. The orcs, on the other hand, along with the goblins, moved forward quickly. Because the goblins can only move four inches at a time, as opposed to the 6 inches that just about everyone else can move, they fell behind the orcs a bit (Note: There are no pictures for the first 3 rounds because I forgot to get my Mom's camera before I started...).
The second turn was basically the same as the first. No one was in range of the other side's archers yet, so no arrows were fired.
The third turn, the orc archers finally got in range of the elves' bows and the elves unleashed a barrage of arrows, but failed to wound anyone.
The evil side gained priority once again. The orc archers were finally in range to return fire, but they failed to hit anyone. The elves, on the other hand, finally found a target and picked off one of the orc archers.
The good side gained priority in the fifth turn as the elven archers unleashed another shower of arrows on the orcs. One orc archer was killed as a result. The goblin archers, who were finally in range, let loose in return and killed one elven archer.
In the sixth turn, the evil side gained priority; the front line of orcs waited for the goblins to catch up to them, in preparation for a charge on the elves. The elves, on the other hand, made their own preparations for combat. The goblin archers managed to pick off one elven archer, while the elves only killed one goblin.
The evil side moved forward slightly, but they couldn't get into combat. The elves, however, charged madly into combat. Three orcs were killed in the fighting, while four elves were taken down (really really bad dice rolls by the elves...tons of 1's). The goblin archers took down another elf, while the elven archers missed again.
The evil side continued to get very good rolls, especially on the front line. Lots of elves were killed there during the next couple of turns. The elven archers also had very poor rolls on their shots, and failed to kill more than a couple of goblins.
After analyzing the the tactics used by the good side, I saw it probably wasn't the best idea to try a flank on both sides. With the small number of troops, when I tried to flank on both sides, I left just a single line of elves on the front, which was stretching them too thin. I also didn't leave any heroes in the front, leaving it very exposed. In retrospect, it might have been better to put the elven captain on the front line as well as some more backup troops, and then have the others with Gil-Galad flank on the side opposite the archers, so that the archers could flank on their side once they took care of the enemy archers. Of course, with the terrible dice rolls that the good side got, that plan may not have worked that well either.
Overall, the evil side's tactic worked well. It also helped that they vastly outnumbered the good side, and so could quickly and effectively stop the good side's flanking maneuvers. I was a bit disappointed that the cave troll wasn't able to do as much damage. I had hoped he could smash through the elves' front line, but he never really got a chance to get into action until late, and then he mostly rolled badly.
In conclusion, I need to get some dice that roll more sixes ;)
Gil-Galad received one wound his first turn in action, but then started rolling better and eventually killed Durburz. By the time he did that, however, all of the elves on his side that had moved with him in a flanking maneuver had been slaughtered or separated from him and the entire elven front line had collapsed, leaving only 3 or 4 elven spearmen to deal with the cave troll, which had finally gotten into action. The elven captain leading the other flanking maneuver managed to keep his elves together better, but they didn't last long either. Eventually, Gil-Galad moved into combat with the cave troll, as did the few remaining elves. The last four elven archers joined into the fray, but were quickly surrounded and cut down. Unfortunately, the cave troll got a lot of really bad dice rolls, but he managed to stay alive for long enough until the evil side gained priority and surrounded the remaining good troops and killed them.
After analyzing the the tactics used by the good side, I saw it probably wasn't the best idea to try a flank on both sides. With the small number of troops, when I tried to flank on both sides, I left just a single line of elves on the front, which was stretching them too thin. I also didn't leave any heroes in the front, leaving it very exposed. In retrospect, it might have been better to put the elven captain on the front line as well as some more backup troops, and then have the others with Gil-Galad flank on the side opposite the archers, so that the archers could flank on their side once they took care of the enemy archers. Of course, with the terrible dice rolls that the good side got, that plan may not have worked that well either.
Overall, the evil side's tactic worked well. It also helped that they vastly outnumbered the good side, and so could quickly and effectively stop the good side's flanking maneuvers. I was a bit disappointed that the cave troll wasn't able to do as much damage. I had hoped he could smash through the elves' front line, but he never really got a chance to get into action until late, and then he mostly rolled badly.
In conclusion, I need to get some dice that roll more sixes ;)














